learning the ropes

Objective: Change the selected voice to “DreamRodes”
Assumptions: TG77 already in VOICE mode and on MEMORY I (internal). (1)

Notation (2):
[Button]
\ – Press
/ – Release
* – Number of repeats
s – Number of seconds

Ex: [Y \ /]*52 / 10s

I have produced short movie clips illustrating each of the ways to select a new voice

(1) This assumption is made to constrain the number of possible ways to change the voice. Without these assumptions, it would be necessary to consider many other paths from different modes. This study would be useful in the evaluation of the ease of use of the Yamaha TG77 in live performance. In live performance environments it is crucial to be able to switch quickly between the most important modes related to the performance.

(2) I considered an XML-based notation format, as I thought it might be useful later on to have the format easily machine-parseable. It seems from first glance that there is a heirarchy of presses and releases. By nesting presses, it is easy to see what happened and when.

<Yes/><Yes/>
<Yes>
<Left/>
</Yes>


This is likely overkill, so I’ll abandon it for now.

I have two suggestions related to voice selection on the TG77:
1. Implementation of a “jog wheel” function in order to scroll through the voice names at variables speeds
2. Implementation of a “search” function to locate the voice without having to scroll through the various banks

“Jog Wheel”
Interestingly, the TG77′s keyboard-counterpart (the Yamaha SY77) has a rotary wheel control which can be used to scroll through voices. I wonder why the designers didn’t do this for the TG77 using the DATA ENTRY slider.

The video below shows the mocked-up jog wheel operation. The DATA ENTRY slider on the TG77 doesn’t have a function when the unit is in Voice Display mode, so I feel this would be a logical use for it. I mocked up the interaction by holding down the “+1/YES” button while moving the slider.

Notation:
[Slider /] / 3s [Slider /] / 2s = 2 operations / 5s

Notes:
This interaction raises several interesting questions.
1. How quickly should the slider move through the voices? A rotary knob with detents has an implied mapping: 1 voice per click. The slider has no detents.
2. What happens if the slider is at the top of its range when the user wants to jog through the voices? The answer to this question is related to how we answer #1… This probably is an area that requires some user testing. Unless moving the slider back down a bit will allow access to the full remaining range of voices, this could
be very frustrating to use. The data entry slider on my Studio Logic SL-1100 behaves a bit like this — and can be frustrating.

Voice Search
In Voice Display Mode, only two of the function buttons are used (F7 and F8). Another button (F6) could be used as a “Search” button. Pressing “F6″ would cause a search dialog box to appear. I think dialogs are beyond the scope of this assignment.

Test 5: Selecting the “DreamRodes” voice by direct numeric entry

When the DreamRodes is selected in Voice display mode, the upper left portion of the screen displays “VOICE-I D05(53)”, which translates to “Voice Mode, Internal Bank – D, patch number 53″. Using this knowledge, we can jump immediately to the DreamRodes any time we have the Internal memory bank selected.

Buttons:
“5″ – [5]
“3″ – [3]
“Enter” – [E]

Notation:
[5 \ /]*1 / 0.5s [3 \ /]*1 / 0.5s [E \ /]*1 / 0.5s = 3 operations / 1.5s

Quality:
If you know the number of the voice you’re selecting, this is the way to go. It requires the least number of operations in the least amount of time. The downside is that it requires what Donald Norman refers to as “knowledge in your head” of a system. You must already know the voice number corresponding to DreamRodes.

Notes:
I assigned short durations to these button presses as they are located close to one another.

Test 4: Selecting the “DreamRodes” voice by using the voice directory

Buttons:
“F8″, to be abbreviated [F8]
“Bank/Select”, to be abbreviated [Bank]
“Right Arrow”, to be abbreviated [>]

Notation:
[F8 \ /] / 1s [Bank \ /]*2 / 2s [> \ /]*1 / 1s = 4 operations / 4s
Quality: It is much easier to find a voice when you can see a bunch of them at a time. The downside of this method is that you must be close to the face of the unit in order to read the names.

Notes:
When the TG77 is in Voice Display mode

the F8 button displays a list of the voices.

Test 3: Selecting the “DreamRodes” voice by pressing and release the “+1/YES” button in cycles

Buttons: “+1/YES”, to be abbreviated [+1]

Notation: ( [+1 \ ] / 1.5s [+1 /] ) * 12 = 24 operations / 18s

Quality: This seems better than simply holding down the “+1″ button if you’re looking for a particular instrument.

Test 2: Selecting the “DreamRodes” voice by holding down the “+1/YES” button

Buttons: “+1/YES”, to be abbreviated [+1]

Notation: [+1 \]*1 / 7s [+1 /]*1 / 0s [-1 \ /]*1 / 1s = 3 operations / 8s

Quality: It is very easy to overshoot the desired voice while holding down the “+1″ button. This technique is not recommended if you don’t remember the name of the instrument you’re looking for.

Test 1: Selecting the “DreamRodes” voice using multiple presses of the “+1/YES” button

Buttons:
“+1/YES”, to be abbreviated [+1]
“-1/NO”, to be abbreviated [-1]

Notation: [+1 \ /]*52 / 10s [-1 \ /]*2 / 1s = 54 operations / 11s

Quality: While pressing [Y] rapidly, I found it was easy to overshoot the desired voice. I would like to try this with someone who is unfamiliar with the instrument as I have grown accustomed to the names of the instruments which precede “DreamRodes”

Note: The video segment lasts longer than the reported 11 seconds because I found later that I could press the button more rapidly than I did while filming and still read the name of the voice.